This
has grown out of the tradition of remedial massage and bonesetting.
Whilst utilizing techniques which resemble osteopathic manipulative
therapy and chiropractic, manipulative therapists regard
their work as being aimed at the physical normalization
of joint and muscle dysfunction, with the objective of improving
mechanical function. No attempt is made to relate the methods
to broader aspects of body function or ill health; indeed
such ideas are actively discouraged by the leaders of this
profession, which sees itself as a system subsidiary to
medicine, in contrast to osteopathy which sees itself as
an alternative.
Most of the work of these therapists involves massage, with
manipulation only being used when considered absolutely
necessary. There are no full time training facilities for
such practitioners who are, as a rule, physiotherapists
or masseurs drawn to these methods. Some are skillful and
competent, but their narrow view as to the value and application
of manipulation, together with their limited approach to
bodily dysfunction, distinguishes them from the osteopathic
practitioner.
Bonesetters
There are still some 'bonesetters' about, especially in
remote rural areas. These are, frequently, gifted healers
carrying on an unwritten tradition of learned and acquired
skills which go back into prehistory.
In England,
there was for many centuries a tradition of bonesetters.
Many of these undoubtedly skilled practitioners had no formal
medical training. In the early eighteenth century a Mrs
Mapp achieved a great following and was consulted by many
doctors.
In 1867 Sir
James Paget, an eminent physician, warned his fellow doctors:
'Few of you are likely to practice without having a bonesetter
for a rival; and if he can cure a case which you have failed
to cure, his fortune will be made and yours marred.'
The fame of
Herbert Barker, an unqualified bonesetter, was so great
that he was eventually knighted for his services. He was
hounded by orthodox medicine and all contact between Barker
and doctors was forbidden on pain of expulsion from the
profession; this, despite his continual stream of successful
cases. In his old age Barker demonstrated his techniques
to a group of orthopaedic surgeons in London, a final admission
of his genius.
Manipulation,
as practiced by bonesetters, was a relatively simple matter
of pushing or pulling restricted joints, to achieve ease
of movement. Sometimes great force was used and frequently
damage was caused by excessive violence. The difference
between such methods and their total lack of any coherent
or systematic use differentiates them from osteopathy.
Massage
Massage has a long history, but not until the nineteenth
century was a systematic approach developed by P. H. Ling
in Sweden. A school of medical gymnastics was founded, and
this promoted the use of 'scientific' massage. Many variations
exist. Some methods are remedial, being aimed at the restoration
of function lost during surgery or because of enforced bed-rest
(accidents, strokes etc.), or through advancing age. Other
methods are used to encourage function in birth injuries
or disease-damaged (polio) patients. Massage techniques
are also used in gaining general relaxation and circulatory
improvements.
Osteopaths
utilize specialized soft-tissue techniques which bear a
superficial resemblance to massage. Both deal with the soft
tissues. The osteopath is either preparing the area for
subsequent manipulation or dealing reflexly with problems
distant from the area being treated. The U.K. trained osteopath
might use a system developed in England known as neuro-muscular
technique. In the U.S.A a similar deep soft tissue method
was developed by the late Ida Rolf. Both these method have
some similarities with the specialized German method of
connective tissue massage (Bindesgewebsmassage) which uses
deep finger and thumb strokes to achieve local and reflex
effects Rolfing aims at releasing deep tissue contractions
and thus encouraging postural and structural reintegration,
and psychological 'release' from emotions which are tied
into muscular stress patterns. Neuro-muscular technique,
rolfing and connective tissue massage are all specialized
soft tissue methods, bearing little in common with what
is normally, thought of as massage.